Is this fair to George Clooney’s fiancé? I don’t think so…


I don’t know George Clooney’s fiancé, Amal Alamuddin.  I don’t know George Clooney (although we once, in passing, had a conversation about our mutual hate for what is going on in Sudan by President Bashir.)  

 I do know Clooney’s fiancé  is a lawyer (I read that some place weeks ago.)  

I also know, but only from reading below, that she has been named to a UN inquiry.  

This posting is NOT about whether such an inquiry should go forward or not.  

This post is about the criticism of Alamuddin serving on the panel because of her age – 36 – and her engagement to a movie start.  See below.

First, 36 is old enough.  36 year olds can do fact investigations (much younger can, too!)  

Second, penalizing her for her soon to be husband is not right.  I doubt she is so feeble minded as to be influenced by a husband in her job (and I have no idea even what Clooney’s views are on this!)

Let me repeat…I don’t know her…I am not making a statement about the inquiry…only making a statement about being fair to her…and her age and pending marriage should not disqualify her.   If there are other reasons to disqualify her, let’s hear them. 


Screen Shot 2014-08-11 at 2.19.03 PM


NGO: William Schabas must recuse himself from UN Gaza inquiry


Clooney fiancee is youngest ever to serve on any UN inquiry


GENEVA, Aug. 11 — A Geneva-based human rights group called on William Schabas to recuse himself from the UN’s new Gaza inquiry, saying that he is legally disqualified by prior statements expressing his wish to see Prime Minister Netanyahu and former President Shimon Peres indicted before the International Criminal Court.


“Under international law, William Schabas is obliged to recuse himself because his repeated calls to indict Israeli leaders obviously gives rise to actual bias or the appearance thereof,” said Hillel Neuer, an international lawyer and executive director of UN Watch, accredited to the United Nations as a non-governmental organization mandated to monitor the world’s body’s adherence to the UN Charter.


“You can’t spend several years calling for the prosecution of someone, and then suddenly act as his judge,” said Neuer. “It’s absurd — and a violation of the minimal rules of due process applicable to UN fact-finding missions.”


Clooney fiancee is youngest ever to serve on any UN inquiry


UN Watch also questioned the appointment of Hollywood star George Clooney’s fiancee Amal Alamuddin as another commissioner. “She has some experience, but at 36 she will be the youngest ever to serve on any UN inquiry, raising suspicions that the UN is trying to inject some Hollywood publicity into the process,” said Neuer.


Prior statements of Schabas demonstrating bias or appearance thereof:


– “My favorite would be Netanyahu within the dock of the International Criminal Court,” Schabas declared last year. (See video at 12:29)


– Schabas was an active participant before a pro-Palestinian “tribunal” that, according to a New York Times op-ed by Judge Richard Goldstone, consisted of one-sided evidence and a jury composed of “critics whose harsh views of Israel are well known.”


– In a law journal article, Schabas wrote that Netanyahu could be considered “the single individual most likely to threaten the survival of Israel.”


– A few years earlier, Schabas called for “going after” Israeli president Shimon Peres in the ICC, saying, “Why are we going after the president of Sudan for Darfur and not the president of Israel for Gaza?”


– In a 2009 blog post about the UN’s infamous Durban II conference on racism, Schabas urged the world not only to “ignore” Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad’s statements, but to stop “exaggerating” them. According to Schabas, those who “deserve the blame” are “Israel and its friends, who have manipulated the truth about the nature of the work of the United Nations by gross exaggeration of the role and intervention of certain fanatics.” Schabas described Ahmadinejad as nothing more than a “provocative politician,” and not a torturer of dissidents, inciter of genocidal anti-Semitism, and arch-sponsor of terrorism.


– In 2011, Schabas went to Iran to co-sponsor conferences with the Tehran-based “Center for Human Rights and Cultural Diversity,” despite its intimate ties with the fundamentalist regime, and avowed propaganda agenda. The center’s director, Kamran Hashemi, a former political officer with Iran’s foreign ministry, wrote his Ph.D under Schabas at the Irish Center for Human Rights.


EU: Resolution creating inquiry is “unbalanced, inaccurate, prejudicial”


In addition, UN Watch stressed that the entire July 23rd resolution creating the inquiry, sponsored by the Arab and Islamic states, was “born in bias,” condemning Israel 18 times, yet never mentioning Hamas once.


The EU refused to support the resolution, saying it was “unbalanced, inaccurate, and prejudges the outcome of the investigation by making legal statements.”


The EU noted that the resolution “also fails to condemn explicitly the indiscriminate firing of rockets into Israeli civilian areas as well as to recognize Israel’s legitimate right to defend itself.”


President Obama’s representative to the UNHRC, Ambassador Keith Harper, described the inquiry as “yet another one-sided mechanism targeting Israel.”